StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Decartes' Argument - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Decartes' Argument" tells us about the relationship between our senses and how we relate them to the outer world. Specialized cells and tissues within these organs receive raw stimuli and translate them into signals the nervous system can use…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
Decartes Argument
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Decartes' Argument"

Descartes tried to figure out the relationship between our senses, experiences, ideas, and reason, and how we relate them to the outer world with the help of his arguments on trusting our senses. He discussed how human nature is prone to believe in its senses and act accordingly. Though our first experiences teach us about the ways to handle particular situations and we learn from nature and personal experiences, one cannot fully trust one’s senses beyond a certain point.

Senses can deceive us in our judgments and understanding of the world around us. We look at and feel the objects around us with our senses- thus our senses are the gateway to understanding the phenomena of the world. However, our senses and perceptions are defined in different ways. Sometimes we do not feel the same way about certain things at different times. As we grow from our infancy to adulthood and beyond, our perceptions change with time, our experiences, and learning. Therefore, we cannot depend upon our senses to comprehend or understand the nature of objects or the world itself.

Our senses give us limited knowledge about other objects or ourselves. For instance, we can sense or feel physical or emotional pain through our senses; yet we cannot ascertain the duration of pain from our previous experiences. This is an everyday example that manifests the limitation of trusting our senses.

Descartes argued that passion led by reason can be trusted to a greater extent. This is because, with each new experience, we learn something new about the way we perceive the world with our senses. If our reasoning faculty is in charge of our senses, we can broaden the areas where we can trust our senses.

The claim is that if, in any particular case, the teachings of nature were untrustworthy, then the veracious God would have given us the means to correct it... we can ... trust the teachings of nature and believe that our sensations proceed from bodies, in spite of the fact that our inclinations are not always trustworthy. But, when another faculty, reason, of course, gives us the means to correct the teachings of nature, then they must be rejected... In the end, Descartes uses sensation to establish the existence of bodies, he is very careful to claim that sensation, by itself, does not establish the nature of bodies. (Rorty, 106)

This is where other philosophers object to Descartes's argument. He believes that senses do not belong to the material world as they keep changing with the change in objects, or sometimes convey the incorrect perception of objects. In contrast, he trusts his reasoning faculty and deems his mind and body separate from each other.  “... where God has given us no means to correct our natural inclination, we must trust it, and in this case, we are entitled to believe that our sensory ideas are caused by an active faculty in bodies.” (Garber, 72)

Descartes based his argument on his sensory perceptions and came to the conclusion that his senses can deceive him. The mind-body dualism theory is contradictory in a number of ways. The separation between mind and body does not establish a relationship between the main faculties of human beings- that is, our senses and reason.

Descartes' argument of senses was a breakthrough in the history of philosophy and the objections that rose against it further developed man’s understanding of his senses and its relationship to reason. Though Descartes overlooked the importance of empirical evidence to support reason, yet his argument proved to be a cornerstone in metaphysical science and philosophy.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Decartes' Argument Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1578141-decartes-argument
(Decartes' Argument Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1578141-decartes-argument.
“Decartes' Argument Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1578141-decartes-argument.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Decartes' Argument

Explain Descartes skeptical argument according to a prompt

He developed two main sceptical arguments to support his argument, the dream doubt argument and the evil demon argument. The dream… t argument can be broken down into parts so as to fully appreciate whether or not we can have knowledge of the external world on the basis of our sensory impressions.... The dream argument can thus be presented as (Descartes 33): The crucial step Descartes make in his dream doubt This lack of insight forms the basis of the argument as the mediator notices that there are certain instances when he is convinced he is awake and surrounded by real objects but he is in fact sleeping and dreaming....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Explain Descartes skeptical argument according to a prompt

His argument raises a tricky condition that seems to be mutually of the utmost ease and to be overwhelming in its impression on our entitlements to know things about the world around us… He says that we might be having the same experiences with mad men.... To strengthen his argument, he uses the dream argument....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Three Main Arguments in the First Meditation of Descartes

n the second argument, the issue centers on uncertainty.... he third argument leads to the existence of a non-deceiving god.... The basic part of the argument centers on the kind of being he exists as.... The researcher of the paper "Three Main Arguments in the First Meditation of Descartes" aims to analyze the main arguments of the beforementioned work and how they are related to each other and to the work as a whole....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Descartes' Wax Argument

From the paper "Descartes' Wax argument" it is clear that Descartes' ability to be introspective allows for his arguments to be evaluated and valued.... The argument he creates makes the path straight for those who are looking for answers regarding the faculties he mentions.... How the mind observes things, why doubt is created, how perception and relativity changes with time, what expression looks like, how the mind, body and soul function as a unit, and how a limited perception affect cognition can be explained by Descartes through is an argument of judgment and imagination....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

Bouwsmas Argument in Descartes Evil Genius

The paper "Bouwsma's argument in Descartes Evil Genius" describes that being one with Tom and his senses implies converging to the truth materialized by these senses so the deceiver settles at no other possible saving choice than comprehend the meaninglessness of the illusions he has built.... n responding to Descartes' argument via the evil demon hypothesis, Bouwsma necessitates the presence of a character that would be designated in the sphere of deception and correspondingly react to the tests over which his sense perceptions are given....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review

Significance of Descartes Two Definition of God

From this definition, it is easy for us to understand Descartes' argument, which implies that the idea of God contains the idea of existence, and hence God must exist and God cannot fail to exist since God's existence is necessary (Lacewing n.... As such, it is clear that Descartes' definition of God helps us to simplify his argument about God's existence....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Descartes' Argument from Illusion

As the paper "Descartes' argument from Illusion" outlines, Descartes argued that real knowledge rested in the mind and not in the senses.... The main argument is on the basis that dreams and reality are very similar.... There is the argument that many times human senses deceive them, and, in fact, those things that they may believe to recognize may be false.... Descartes' argument has much emphasis when we connect it to many human experiences....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Rene Descartes' Evil Genius Argument

The paper "Rene Descartes' Evil Genius argument" suggests Descartes's attempt to overcome the evil demon was unsuccessful.... hellip; Descartes' evil genius argument is the argument that he advanced to demonstrate that all sensory knowledge can be doubted.... Descartes goes in the argument to regard his hands, eyes, flesh, and his senses as the illusions that the evil genius has made him believe are real while in an actual sense are mere illusions....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us