StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Arguments in Favor of Donation - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Arguments in Favor of Donation" focuses on our moral duty to help those in need. It, however, is a plausible argument that donations in the form of cash or food should only be given in cases of extreme emergencies like earthquakes or famine otherwise they cause dependency. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Arguments in Favor of Donation
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Arguments in Favor of Donation"

An Argument Paper in Favor of DONATION

It is the moral responsibility of every human being to help those in need of help with everything they can, no matter how geographically distanced the needy lives are. However, many people have a different points of view regarding this notion. According to Peter Singer, some people argue that people should be allowed to follow their own beliefs regarding donating money as everyone has a different take on the issue (Singer 25). However, this can be a deceptive argument as allowing everyone to freely profess his or her beliefs might not bring good to society. For example, we do not allow students to cheat in exams or people to violate speed regulations just because they think it is a fun thing to do. There are laws that restrict such behavior which is considered moral relativism. Similarly, not donating to the needy can also be termed as moral relativism and must be discouraged.

Another moral obligation that most people agree to be saving a drowning child. It does not matter whether the drowning child is related to us or is our responsibility at all. All that matters is that a human being is in distress and it is our moral duty to save him even at the cost of sacrificing our own comfort or belongings. We just cannot shy away from the responsibility by saying that “he’s not my baby” or “I was not babysitting for him”. Similar is the case of donating a reasonable amount of money to the children who are striving to stay alive because of famine or hunger throughout the world. At this point, it should be clearly understood that it does not matter whether the children you are donating for are of the same country, religion, or cast. Similar to saving the drowning child who could be an American, a non-Christian, or even a migrant, what matters is that we have to help a human being in distress even if it means sacrificing our own belongings.  

People often say that they have worked hard for the money they have earned and it is their right to spend it on buying a new car, redecorating the house, or buying new clothes (Singer 26). However, what people do not understand is that it is not their right to spend money on the things they choose. If that be the case, government taxation would be an option and not a compulsion. Comparable to this is an example of a person who does not choose to donate to the needy and therefore exercises the right to choose a wrong attitude. In fact, such people might not be in a proper moral condition to feel the situation in which the needy are. Suitable sympathetic feelings for the needy can be experienced only after appropriate reflection and research which would enable people to determine the extent of help they can and should extend. This would not only facilitate righteous self-development but also enable individuals to live their lives as they deem fit. If a wealthy individual enjoys sunbathing at luxurious beach hotels or balls at casinos while millions of others are in dire need of some part of his wealth then it is morally wrong for him to live his life as per his choice; saying “I have earned the money and I have a right to spend it as I please”.

Some people also oppose the notion that it is our moral responsibility to help those in need by saying that although they have a responsibility towards those whom they have wronged, they do not have any responsibility towards those whom they have not wronged (Singer 28). This can be termed as an extreme view the fact that if this argument is accepted as reasonable, no charity would work for the jobless, the disabled, or the famine-stricken people. This also entails that help to the needy should also not be restricted to the boundaries of one’s neighborhood, city, or even country. Help should and must be extended to all without prejudice to boundaries in a manner that one is fulfilling a moral obligation.

Some people feel that the USA is already giving generously in terms of aid to underdeveloped nations, which is enough and there is no need to donate more (Singer 33). However, the fact is totally the opposite! According to the figures OECD released in 2006, the USA donated 18 cents per $100 of GNI which is much less than what other developed countries are donating (Singer 33). Take for example a person who sees a drowning child and waits for another child to fall into the pool to save both at the same time. Similarly, because there is so much poverty in the world that we cannot save every suffering human being does not justify our notion not to save some of them (Wellman 317).

The discussion on donations for the needy is not near its end however, the arguments in favor of donating prove that it is our moral duty to help those in need. It, however, is a plausible argument that donations in the form of cash or food should only be given in cases of extreme emergencies like earthquakes or famine otherwise they cause dependency. The notion of “Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime” fits here perfectly (Smith 10). Donations should be given in such a form that they encourage the needy to earn their own money and sustain their own living.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Argument paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1488452-argument-paper
(Argument Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1488452-argument-paper.
“Argument Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1488452-argument-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Arguments in Favor of Donation

Arguments for Miranda Rights

Those in favor of Miranda Rights must deal with the thought that they do not really change or better society in any substantive way.... The paper "arguments for Miranda Rights" portrays a protective mechanism for those accused of crimes in the US, and it is an extension of the Fifth Amendment protection of due process.... arguments against Miranda Rights have to contend with counter-arguments that not having this protective mechanism in place will open citizens to potential rights abuses, and not having this mechanism will remove a key set of information that individuals need when dealing with police....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

The recent Supreme Court decision allowing large corporations to run their own political ads

Whereas some people have been in favor of the ruling, others have strongly contested the decision, terming it a threat to democracy (Carney 2).... Therefore, the ruling will not favor republicans, but it will favor the most promising or prominent party.... For as much as the ruling might have negative implications on the federal elections, these arguments are not true and, as far as I am concerned, the decision will not have drastic effects on the politics of the United States of America, especially the elections....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Should Willingness To Donate Be Assumed Unless The Individual Has Opted Out

People who voice in favor of the argument state that the world needs to broaden its canvas when it wants to paint a picture of human safety and security.... The paper discusses the concept of organ donation and the focus of the argument would be on the controversial topic of assumed consent of the person until he or she has opted out of the organ donation after death, in other words, presumed consent until opted out.... It can be said that the concept of presumed consent in organ donation practice has certain positives, such that the total organs donated will unquestionably increase and that the concept of altruism will also get its full worth, but the disadvantages outshine the benefits....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Hange and the importance of adapting to a dynamic world

In The Rise of the Rest, Fareed Zakaria identifies “three tectonic power shifts” (Zarkaria, 2008, 611) in global politics, economics and culture: the ‘Rise of the West', the ‘Rise of the USA', and the ‘Rise of the Rest.... He argues that there is now an unprecedented, truly global growth and political awakening, which challenges the US dominance of the world....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Ethics of Organ Donation and Transplantation into the United States

In this form of donation, organs are donated from the recently deceased.... This essay "Ethics of Organ donation and Transplantation into the United States" is about a deficiency in the policies and programs employed to increase organ donation because it neither significantly increased the rate of organ donation nor did it succeed in protecting the rights of donors.... Organ donation, defined as a high technology medicine that is used to intervene at the end stage of an illness, unlike other medical technologies, is considered to be an altruistic process because it requires the 'gift' of organs from others to proceed....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Stem Cell Research

In this paper, the author outlines the general arguments in favor of, and against, stem cell research, and argues finally that certain areas of the research are morally unjustifiable. ... In this paper, the author outlines the general arguments in favor of, and against, stem cell research, and argues finally that certain areas of the research are morally unjustifiable.... On the other hand, there are good arguments in favor of stem cell research....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Political Theory of Machiavelli

The aim of the present essay is to provide two main arguments in favor of the political theory of Machiavelli.... Following the logic of Abramson, one can find two main arguments in favor of the validity of Machiavelli's theory.... Thus, the aim of the paper is to provide two main arguments in favor of the political theory of Machiavelli....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Should Organ Donors Be Paid For Their Organs

This paper "Should Organ Donors Be Paid For Their Organs" discusses organ donation as a process that whereby organs and other body tissues are removed and transplanted from a donor to a receiver.... Nevertheless, individual states have put in place State legislation that eases the difficult rigors of organ donation.... The decision arrived at towards the end of 2011 was following a lawsuit launched in October 2009 by parents, cancer patients and bone-marrow-donation crusaders against the federal government over a national law outlawing the sale or purchase of bodily organs....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us