StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Socrates Apology - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Socrates Apology" states that there is a version written by Xenophon, but it is not considered as authentic since he was not present during the time of the trial even though Plato was. In fact, Plato himself was mentioned twice by Socrates in his apology. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
Socrates Apology
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Socrates Apology"

? Socrates’ Apology Socrates was a Greek Athenian thinker, famous for his work on philosophy,including some plays and also as the tutor of pupils like Plato. The Apology is a document written by Plato in which he has noted down the apology Socrates made when he was put on trial due to certain accusations put against him. There is also another version written by Xenophon, but it is not considered as authentic since he was not present during the time of the trial even though Plato was. In fact, Plato himself was mentioned twice by Socrates in his apology. We cannot be sure of Xenophon’s text because it is all a result of word of mouth, but then he has added some more background information, too. Yet another account of the trial is given by Aristophanes, a comic playwright. The philosopher was a member of the sub-council – the Council of Five Hundred – that ruled over the Assembly. His morals, way of thinking did not create much of a fuss at first. He did all that he thought was right, nothing more and then a time came when Athens was under attack and Sparta won the battle. The Greeks were humiliated and angry, especially when Socrates did not seem to approve of their form of government. He was considered as a critic of the then governmental system of Greece and due to this and other things he was accused against, he was put on trial by Anytus, Lycon and Meletus – the latter being the prosecutor who was mostly responsible for putting Socrates on trial. "Socrates does injustice and is meddlesome, by investigating the things under the earth and the heavenly things, and by making the weaker speech the stronger, and by teaching others these same things" (Plato, West and West 66). The above were the charges placed against Socrates and he had to plead innocent or guilty for them. In simple words, Socrates’ thoughts were not similar to the thoughts the Greeks generally had. He believed that the gods knew everything, were present everywhere, one could not hide anything or anyone from them. The majority of the Greeks thought that the gods were partially present, that they knew some things and remained unaware about others. Their concepts of gods was different and it was not that much of a problem until Socrates actually refused to follow an order regarding to agreeing to allowing something illegal to happen. He had taken a vow and believed that the gods would know he had done wrong and for this he was being put on trial, for going against what they thought was god’s will when, in fact, it was just their own. The wording of this charge of impiety makes one assume that Socrates did not believe in the gods which were worshipped by the people of Athens, but also that he did not believe in the authority of gods at all. When, in fact, that was not the case and Socrates proves them wrong at several points in his apology. Socrates relates an incident in which Chaerephon, a friend of his and also quite a famous personality in the city, went to the Oracle of Delphi and actually questioned whether anyone was wiser than Socrates and the reply was in negative. The philosopher believed this to be a paradox in itself since he did not consider himself to be the wisest person, but thought it to be true, too, so he spent his entire life trying to prove the Oracle of Delphi correct. On questioning a few of the prominent Athenians who were thought to be wise, Socrates only managed to conclude that, indeed, he was the wisest of all of them. This was because he was aware of the fact that he was still ignorant of many things of life, whilst the others thought they were intelligent enough, they did not think that there might be room for further improvement, etc. and that was the paradox itself. The fact that he knew he was ignorant and the others did not proved that he was the Oracle was right. This point did seem to humiliate the respected men and only managed to turn them against him though. But it also shows that Socrates wanted the Oracle to be right and if he did not believe in any gods, he would not have devoted his life trying to prove the Oracle right. Later onwards, there is a cross questioning session between Metelus and Socrates in which the former accuses the later of being an atheist, and in the same breath says he is responsible for creating new gods. Over here, too, Socrates uses his quick mind to prove himself innocent of the charge. If was, indeed, an unbeliever, then he could not have possibly introduced new gods, that was just contradictory in itself. Either he was a believer but did not worship the same gods as others, but he was being accused of not believing in any gods at all and this proved Metelus wrong. Another reason for bringing Socrates to court was that he was accused of feeding wrong ideas to the youth. He had his own pupils who he shared his ideas with and when he even mentioned them to the young population, he must have had an influence on them. But the point is that whether he did or not, it was not his fault. He just spoke about what he believed in, he did not force anyone to listen to him. In fact, he did not even ask for money from his pupils despite him not being well off at all. His way of thinking was different from the rest, more liberal maybe even because of the political conditions of the time he was growing in. Pericles was a great and prominent Greek statesman of his time, but what he also was was liberal, promoting arts and literature. It is possible that Socrates may have been influenced by his line of thought though this is rarely considered when the fairness or unfairness of Socrates’ trial is discussed. But, accusing Socrates for changing someone’s minds due to his ideas was not really something he should have been into trial for. The ‘apology’ made by Socrates to the court is not the apology one would naturally assume to be, he is not admitting he is wrong and asking to make amends for his mistake. During those times in Greece, by apology they meant that a person is defending his own beliefs and thoughts and even actions. Over here, Socrates is defending his actions; he is trying to prove himself as innocent of all the charges pressed against him. Unfortunately though, Socrates is voted guilty. Despite the fact he repeatedly proves himself to be innocent; he still loses his case, which did not even have any grounds in the first place. The man’s beliefs, his actions were just that – his own, and it was just a matter of perception. Some might have agreed with his teachings, some – quite obviously – did not, but this did not mean that they could sentence him to death. Even though he is given several chances of escaping from his prison, he refuses to do so, knowing that the story, his story being told to the future generations, years later would bring about more of an impact to their minds than if he escaped. The fact that he had to drink hemlock and walk around till he became numb and eventually died would prove to the people that one should remain adamant at what one believes in and not give in even when facing the possibility of death. Works Cited Plato, Thomas G. West and Grace Starry West. 4 Texts on Socrates. Cornell University Press, 1998. Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Apology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Apology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1459505-apology
(Apology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Apology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1459505-apology.
“Apology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1459505-apology.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Socrates Apology

What Is the Main Difference between Aristotle's Account of Virtue and Socrates' Account of Virtue

The views of philosophers, like socrates and.... At a first level, both socrates and Aristotle refer to virtue as a general term – i.... However, socrates In this way, Aristotle has accepted the Socrate's account of virtue as related to courage but he is differentiated from socrates to the following point: courage, which, in the form of knowledge, is for socrates the basis of virtue (Kahn 1998, p.... The differences regarding the views of socrates and Aristotle on virtue are analytically presented below; explanations are given, as possible by referring to the relevant texts....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Heights of Athenian Domination

In his apology, Plato has recorded the last days of Socates' life.... socrates lived his life during a period when there was a great deal of transition from the heights of Athenian domination till the time such domination declined after Sparta and its allies became victorious over Athens.... The public in Athens was doubtful about democracy being an effective form of governance and in this perspective, socrates, who appeared to be a strong critic of democracy, was defended by many who interpreted his trial as being an outcome of internal political strife....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Aristotles Criteria and Apology by Socrates

Consequently, he discards the claim made by Plato in his apology that human imagination serves as a copy of real natural phenomena, and poetry is the copy of that imagination; consequently, poetic work is mere the copy of the copy of reality, which should not be accepted altogether.... It is therefore the apology criticizes all forms of art, either performing or verbal or written, by declaring them as strictly against moral values and reality....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Apology Plato

Complete Preview / Analysis of Plato's “apology of Socrates” In the book, Plato's “apology of Socrates” comprises an account of the three speeches which Socrates boldly delivered in order to have justice sought against the allegations that point to his deliberate will of not recognizing philosophical conventions as well as of misleading the youth of Athens to his non-traditional or unique learning pedagogy.... It would be quite apparent after reading and analyzing the text that Plato attempts to convey how the impact of the ‘apology of Socrates' guides and substantiates his own wisdom on what could make the capacity for evolving knowledge turn into a desire for destructive gain rather than enlightenment of humanity....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Research paper The Apology of Socrates

Socrates acknowledges these charges when he speaks against old enemies that have spoken falsely “telling of one Socrates, a wise man, who speculated about the heaven above, and searched into the earth beneath, and made the worse appear the better cause” (apology: 944).... But I observed that even the good artisans fell into the same error as the poets; because they were good workmen they thought that they also knew all sorts of high matters, and this defect in them overshadowed their wisdom” (apology: 947)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Three Important Lessons: PLato's Apology

The author of the "Three Important Lessons: Plato's apology" paper focuses on Plato's 'apology' which is a recounting of the speech that Socrates was thought to have given in 399 BC to defend himself against various charges brought against him by his accusers.... His apology was a lecture on the triumph of knowledge over ignorance and he was beseeching his listeners to discard old and traditional beliefs and embrace modern intellectual development....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Socrates view on death

The apology by Plato gives an in depth account of the trial and death of Socrates who was being tried on two accounts of corrupting the young minds with his philosophies and failing to honor the gods being worshiped in Athens.... SOCRATES' apology Introduction The apology by Plato gives an in depth account of the trial and death of Socrates who was being tried on two accounts of corrupting the young minds with his philosophies and failing to honor the gods being worshiped in Athens....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Analysis of Socrates' Apology

This book review "Analysis of Socrates' apology" contextualizes and considers Socrates' claim that a better person cannot be harmed by a worse one, delving into evidence from the apology and offering a personal response to Socrates' main line of philosophical reasoning.... Plato's apology considers Socrates' trial in front of the Greek lawmakers.... he apology begins with Socrates expending considerable effort to demonstrate how he came to partake in his role as an expounder of wisdom and intellectual thought....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us