StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

Comparative Analysis - Essay Example

Summary
An adequate account of what conditions need to be satisfied in order for a claim on something to be called a “right” to that something has not…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.2% of users find it useful
Comparative Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparative Analysis"

Download file to see previous pages

But it is precisely this step that many philosophers, and the majority of mankind, find problematic: how can we give rights to beings that, according to our customs, are to be used merely as ends to our satisfaction? This view was first introduced in the 18th century by the German philosopher Immanuel Kant who, in his article “Rational Beings Alone Have Moral Worth”, proposed that only rational beings are subjected to the famous categorical imperatives because only rational beings can discover the moral laws that govern all action.

Non-rational animals, then, are to be excluded from the moral equation, subtracted out based on their inherent limitation. This view, oddly, still dominates the modern mindset, even though it is a two hundred year-old theory. Modern theorists, however, disagree on Kant’s points about rationality being the criterion of moral worth. Peter Singer and Tom Regan, of course, are two who dispute Kant’s claims, and have productively advanced the contemporary debate on the rights of animals. However, as we shall see, their arguments are not without their own problems, and perhaps go too far in what they hope to accomplish.

Peter Singer, in his “A Utilitarian Defense of Animal Rights”, and Tom Regan, in his “The Radical Egalitarian Case for Animal Rights”, both focus on the central focus of Kant’s paper: that of the distinction between direct and indirect duties. Kant’s position is clearly that humans have no direct duties to animals, but only indirect duties. For instance, if a person runs over his neighbor’s dog, then we should not say that we have wronged the dog in some way, but rather that we have wronged the owner, a man to whom one does have direct duties toward.

And since the dog was of value to the man, we have an indirect duty not to run over the dog. This, of course, justifies the usage of animals in testing harmful products, meat and dairy consumption, and other

...Download file to see next pages Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparative Analysis

Slavery Comparative Analysis

The essay "Slavery Comparative Analysis" focuses on the criticla analysis of the origins and peculiarities of slavery in two books, James Macpherson's Ordeal by Fire and Stanley Elkins's Slavery.... In this essay, I will give a Comparative Analysis of the construal of slavery in two books, James Macpherson's ordeal by fire and Stanley Elkins' slavery....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Comparative Analysis of Advertisements

Instructor Date Comparative Analysis of Advertisements Pepsi and Coca-Cola are two companies in the soft drink industry which demonstrate an increasing rivalry in the market to promote their products and brands.... The view of the essay is to employ a critical analysis approach in order to present a unique comparison and contrasting of the advertising approach of the two multinational companies....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces

The essay "Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces" will carry out a Comparative Analysis of two altarpieces created in the renaissance period: Fra Angelico's The San Marco Altarpiece and Robert Campin's The Merode Altarpiece, with emphasis on similarities and differences.... This essay will carry out a Comparative Analysis of two altarpieces created in the renaissance period.... Comparative Analysis of Altarpieces In art, a Comparative Analysis is the process that enables one to study in detail a piece of artwork by observing the application of elements, concepts, and ideas....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Media comparative analysis

A media Comparative Analysis has a vital role in comprehending the various essential elements of the changing nature of the media.... Such a media Comparative Analysis deals with the social aspects, the assumptions and logics, the industrial, the commercial contexts, the primary functions, etc of a particular media form, technology, process, or event in relation to the explicit or implied research methods, the critical framework and assumptions, the theories and logics, the methods and worldviews etc of a specific reading on media and media function....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

International Comparative Analysis

This essay describes the approach of an international Comparative Analysis, that will allow for an honest evaluation of what went wrong with previous policies about the urban renewal efforts of cities and a new insight derived from other countries' experience can guide the way for the planners.... International Comparative Analysis is highly recommended because doing it will provide a good opportunity for testing both theories and policies being implemented to the urban renewal efforts of cities....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Comparative analysis Essay

Ken Robinson in his TED talks argues that the modern education system has refused to evolve with other socioeconomic aspects of life.... He argues that the.... ... ... Today, the economy has changed from being an industrial economy and has been reshaped to be an information economy.... Yet, too many Roger Scruton (2010) on the other hand looks at the issue of the modern education from another perceptive....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Skills Cross Comparative Analysis

The paper "Skills Cross Comparative Analysis" presents that management concerns how a business organization oversees the structure, the assets, and the operations in an organization.... ross Comparative Analysis of the Skills that are Vital for Business Managers ... he Oxford Handbook of Comparative Institutional analysis (Oxford Handbooks in Business and Management) OUP Oxford, New York.... (2012) Handbook of research on comparative human resource management, Edward Elgar, London. ...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Artworks Comparative Analysis

The paper 'Artworks Comparative Analysis' presents an analysis of the following artworks: 'Apollo and Daphne', 'The Conversion of St.... Comparative Analysis ... omparative analysis ... Paul's on the Way to Damascus', 'The pleasures of the ball', 'Portrait of Madame de Pompadour', 'Happy Hazards of the Swing', 'Portrait of Sultan Mehmed II','Kangxi Emperor Practicing Calligraphy'....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us