StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

'Does Country Matter' - Summary and Critque - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Because past studies in the area of business performance had focused on diversified businesses, the differences in and between them, and were carried out in single countries, these researchers contended that country differences would have impact on performance…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Does Country Matter - Summary and Critque
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "'Does Country Matter' - Summary and Critque"

1. 'Does Country Matter' - Summary and Critque Because past studies in the area of business performance had focused on diversified businesses, the differences in and between them, and were carried out in single countries, these researchers contended that country differences would have impact on performance. While agreeing with many of the differences highlighted in such studies (e.g. political, social, economic, institutional etc.) they took a broader approach. They examined 'foreign affiliates' these being 'independent units wholly or partially managed or controlled by a foreign firm in a host country', by defining levels of effect on their performance/returns. a) The question is, how much does country difference actually explain the variations in achievements of foreign affiliates To answer this, the elements they defined were as follows: Country effects, Industry effects, Multinational Corporation (MNC) effects, Affiliates effects and the Years observed, analyzing these to see how they all contributed to the average return or business success achieved by the foreign affiliates.

They hypothesized that country had an important role to play and had not been explored fully in earlier research. b) Methodology The study is described as unique by the researchers because it uses performance of foreign affiliates as the primary unit of analysis, the country effects variables contained in it, and non-U.S. data, only Japanese MNCs. Data was taken from the Trend Survey of Overseas Business Activities (Trend Survey), annually conducted by the Japanese Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry.

The companies used were: either subsidiary (MNC has 10% capital invested),sub-subsidiary (MNC has 50% invested) or where a sub-subsidiary has 50% capital invested in the foreign affiliate company. 12,000 total, over 6 years were examined, using 616 2.Japanese MNCs, in 159 industries and 79 host countries. The variables applied were those described in the 'effects'. c) Results and conclusions suggest that country effects are almost as great as industry effects, implying that the host country has great impact when determining performance, with the two effects being combined having greater impact.

It was also found that in less developed countries these two had greater impact than corporate effects, but overall, corporate effects were found to be greater than anything. These were found to be greater than figures previously reported in earlier research. d) Limitations identified- The research did not examine 'why' variations occurred. Further study is needed to examine country-specific factors. The study only focused on MNCs originating in Japan and so findings may not be relevant to other home countries.

Recommendation is that studies are carried out simultaneously to include home and host countries. They did not look at 'entry mode', how affiliates became part of MNCs and any further study should control for entry mode in analysis. They suggested too, that aggregation problems might exist on two counts, 1) definition of country and 2) definition of industry. Further studies could examine regional effects for variations as well as country effects. e) Assessment of General Relevance of Article: After studying the article, I believe that the researchers have succeeded in supporting their original hypothesis and have identified further relevant facts.

The presentation is clear and easily comprehended, the tables assisting with interpretation. While the appendices give 'names and numbers' for countries and industries, they do not directly contribute to my knowledge of the management of technology. It would have been more helpful and relevant had the names of the MNCs and the industries they control been included, though I accept that this piece of research is directed more towards defining sales and productivity outcomes and not specific to technical or other industries.

It was interesting and informative and the further research identified regarding industry definition would be helpful. Works CitedMakino, S., Isobe, T., & Chan, C.M. Does Country Matter Strategic Management Journal 25 (2004) pp 1027-1043 Published Online in Wiley InterScience www.interscience.wiley.com DOI: 10.1002/smj.412

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“'Does Country Matter' - Summary and Critque Essay”, n.d.)
'Does Country Matter' - Summary and Critque Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526477-does-country-matter-summary-and-critque
('Does Country Matter' - Summary and Critque Essay)
'Does Country Matter' - Summary and Critque Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526477-does-country-matter-summary-and-critque.
“'Does Country Matter' - Summary and Critque Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526477-does-country-matter-summary-and-critque.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF 'Does Country Matter' - Summary and Critque

Disobedience according to Erich Fromm

summary: The essay “Disobedience is a Psychology and Moral problem” was first published in the year 1963.... Disobedience was a psychological and moral problem, where people always tried to be obedient to the ruling people and always want to be doing what the ruling authority like, but with the development of freedom and independence it was absolutely necessary that people must get disobedience in certain parameters to ensure that people leave freely in their country or state or province....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Heteronormativity and Heterosexism

"Heteronormativity and Heterosexism" paper argues that heteronormative culture has brought the debate over homosexuality and same-sex parents to the public arena.... Heteronormativity imposes negative connotations on the stated life choice and classifies it as something that is contradictory to the norm… Emphasizing ordinariness highlights the similarities between the everyday lives of gay/lesbian and heterosexual families....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Book Report Asian Americans

With the growth of worldwide globalization systems, it could not be denied that many people are transferring from one country to another.... Sucheng Chan is a Chinese writer who is fond of writing about the everyday matters of living that connects with her people.... Her book Asian Americans actually outlines the major facts about the lives of Asian immigrants within the American territories....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Power, Desire, Difference

There are four dormant issues between feminism and psychoanalysis, and how to move beyond them.... The issues are: the prominence of Lacan's 'symbolic', sexual difference and knowledge, the bearing of essentialism on feminist politics, and the relation between psychical reality and the issues on women (Chodorow: 1998)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Review of Capital Market in a Small Country: The Case of Slovenia Article by Jochen R Andritzky

The paper on ‘Capital Market in a Small country: The Case of Slovenia' written by Jochen R Andritzky was published in 2007 by the International Monetary Fund as one of its working papers.... The paper basically deals with the strategies to develop more developed capital… Though the study has dealt with a case study of Slovenia, ideal to be called economically a small country, the paper sets a model for capital market development in smaller countries....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Summary of Crime and Violence and Political Rights

The article written by Fernandez and Kuenzi attempts to explore the relationship between the citizens' perceptions of crime and safety and performance of democracy in a country.... The findings of this research report are of great value because they succeed in establishing a relationship which is extremely important to further establishment and consolidation of democracy in any country.... Nicaragua is the largest Central American country, yet the crime rate here is lower compared to the rest of the region under study....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Does Wealth Inequality Matter

Wealth distribution and inequality matters most not because it stokes the flames leading to envy, but because it drives debilitating dissension and creates instability in the society.... However, the best means to address the political problem of envy is undoing the system of the… Those systems do turn those who are envy into a perverse alliance with the most prideful of all (Keister & Moller 2000). Sustained growth is vital for the reduction of The rapid growth and development that has been witnessed in several parts of the world over the last years has led to a significant decrease in the levels of poverty....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

A Summary of the Film

This paper ''A summary of the Film'' tells that Humor turns out to be an essential aspect to keep the viewer's bound when a romantic movie is created on a low budget.... But they must have employed other means of communication, but the call of the sailor's duty from a Communist country beats all further consideration.... The love story in which the sailor is involved could have been a local sailor from her own country England....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us