StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The A/P System - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay explores whether outsourcing the A/P project the right move for Tegan given the other possible alternatives and what are the tradeoffs involved in having the requirements analysis for a project performed by one of the firms that would ultimately bid on the project…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
The A/P System
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The A/P System"

1. Was outsourcing the A/P project the right move for Tegan given the other possible alternatives? IT department of Tegan c.c.c. could have handled the A/P project by its own but its staff strength of 100 was divided equally for the rollout of its comprehensive SAP R-3 project and the rest of the information technology function management. The huge talent pool of Tegan was dedicated to the SAP R-3 project and only a few personnel of the IT department could be made available to rewrite the system. No expert of the originally developed A/P was available other than the singular name that was Julia Jones, as the personnel who developed the system had retired. Time was a big issue with Tegan t to be devoted to the A/P project (Upton and Staats, “Tegan” 2). Another option with the IT department was to function on an enterprise resource planning system (ERP) to include the financial accounting module in the currently processing SAP but the cost factor( £ 5 million) proved a big hindrance (Upton and Staats, “Tegan” 3). The A/P system was taken from an old version of a packaged software system, named Dunnock, which has been customized internally and externally many times. Working on the strength of a singular expert would have been a deadly experience had Tegan opted to manage the A/P project on its own. Outsourcing the A/P project, therefore, was the right move on the part of Tegan (Upton and Staats, “Tegan” 2). 2. What are the tradeoffs involved in having the requirements analysis for a project performed by one of the firms that would ultimately bid on the project? Tradeoffs involved in letting one of the bidding companies to perform the requirement analysis were that it could know the functionality of the current system to be repeated ditto on a scalable system employing newer technologies, robust enough to manage huge volumes. By interviewing the users of the system, Hrad, the bidding company could easily prepare a requirements document and get a view of the work involved and offer a genuine bid amount cost-efficiently, which in turn provided a realization to Tegan that they were accepting a bid, which was not demanding exorbitant cost to complete the project (Upton and Staats 3). Further, It presented the opportunity to Tegan clinch the deal with Hrad on a fixed price condition (Upton and Staats, “Tegan” 4). 3. Given our journeys through the world of system development methods in recent lectures, discuss the choice of development methodology employed by Hrad Technika. Development methodology used by Hrad was formal work breakdown methodology, which was used for bidding on the project. Such an approach offered the leverage of the insight on Tegan’s processes sufficient enough to offer a reasonable quote to gain the contract. Hrad could discuss the intricacies of the project with the experts from Tegan, specific business rules and different customizations (Uptron and Staats, “Hrad Technika” 3). Actual work on system development started with the developing of the draft. All the documents related to defined needs were passed to Tegan for getting the LLD. Hrad used the waterfall method to finish the project. As per the waterfall method, Hrad finished the LLDs first of all and then started the coding. To shorten the development cycle of the project, Hrad started working on coding soon after getting clearance from Jones on LLDs (Uptron and Staats, “Hrad Technika” 4). 4. Why did Hrad Technika, the firm that performed the requirements analysis, have scope and requirements problems once the project commenced? From their side, Hrad employees tried heir best to get an estimate of the work by interviewing the current users of the A/P system but when the actual work began with the rewriting of the LLDs, they found the needed functionality missing. On verification it was found that such issues were not the part of the scope of the project. Nonetheless, with the defining of each module, the coding was started a bit advance before completing the remaining design details. Had Hrad completed the design details before starting coding, it would have realized the approaching problems; speedy overlapping of the waterfall model resulted in making an error on the scoping of the project (Uptron and Staats, “Tegan” 3-4). By August 2008, designing was still going on although the project had reached the stage of half-completed. Problems arose because certain issues had cropped up related to system features like calculating forecasting algorithms for choosing and ordering payments were not there in the earlier conducted scope analysis. Late turning of LLDs by Tegan was another reason besides the missing data from the needs documents created problems for Hrad (Uptron and Staats, “Tegan” 5). 5. The case writers’ state: "Sadly, Smith knew that “Leadership” and “Commitment”, the paucity of which was blamed for untold IT failures were not the problems here." Critique- do you agree? What do you see as the most important IT management failures here? Certainly, failure of the project could not be blamed on the lack of leadership and commitment. The fault was somewhere else. First, Tegan could not handle the project by its own because of not only huge investment required but also due to the primary reason that it lacked the expertise on its own A/P project and neither the company Dunnock had sufficient staff to brief Hrad on its old version of a packaged software system. Only one person at Tegan was available who could help Hrad, as she had worked as an apprentice on the originally developed A/P system and she was not willing but had to help by default, as there was no one in Tegan to help the team at Hrad to know the basics of the A/P system. People in the company had moved away from Tegan and some had retired leaving a cruch of needed staff behind. The main reason of the delay in delivering the project was crunch of staff at Tegan to turn the LLDs back to Hrad after crucial feedback. It compelled the IT team at Hrad to follow a methodology, called the “waterfall methodology” in a haste to overlap the coding before completing the designing, resulting in late finding of certain issues, which were not part of the contract, as decided in the scoping of the project. This was the most crucial IT management failure to start work on coding without finalizing the design of the project. 6. Which of the options for moving forward that Tegan identified would you recommend? Tegan zeroed-in on four alternatives to come out of the crisis. One option was to let Hrad continue with the project, as Hrad had already completing almost half job on developing work. The second option was to include in the in-house project, the SAP’s accounts payable module but it was quite costly. That was the main reason of outsourcing the job to outside company that could deliver the A/P project cost-effectively and also there was a crunch of experts at Tegan to be devoted to additional module to be developed in-house. The third option with Tegan was to temporarily patch the current system by devoting resources but it could not be a permanent solution given the problems faced in the A/P functionality to bear the load of visitors’ rush. Finding another vendor was the last option, which could not be justified, as already Tegan had made payments to Hrad on the work completed as per the conditions of the contract (Uptron and Staats, “Tegan” 6). Considering the four options stated above, it would be in the best interest of Tegan to move forward with Hrad by not insisting on timely delivery of the project, as things did not turn up in the right direction because Tegan could not provide sufficient experts to clear the backlog of LLDs, which happened to be the major cause of overlapping and delay. Works Cited Case Studies Upton, David. M. and Staats, Bradley R. Hrad Technika. Harvard Business School. 21 October 2008 Upton, David. M. and Staats, Bradley R. Tegan c.c.c. Harvard Business School. 31 October 2008. . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The A/P System Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
The A/P System Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/information-technology/1583925-information-system-case-study
(The A/P System Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
The A/P System Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/information-technology/1583925-information-system-case-study.
“The A/P System Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/information-technology/1583925-information-system-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The A/P System

The Project of A/P at Tegan

The third main and pure outsource options require to develop a completely new system for the business A/p system development.... nbsp;… The author states that these can be related to again outsourcing options for the business, corporate internal development, implementation of the SAP enterprise resource planning system, applying additional resources to the existing system development, developing a new patch to add new capabilities in the system....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Tegan/Hrad Technika case

The company would have considered alternative option of Direct Contract with the Dunnock system developer for improvements in existing A / p system.... The reason behind this is the fact Tegan Company made various customizations and self – adjustments in the information system known as… Indeed, the Tegan management did not analyze that they barely had a single employee (Julia Jones) that had command over most of the features / tools of the system....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Tegan And Hrad Technika

/P was experiencing problems and Tegan was continuously thinking about dealing with the problems with the A/p system but Tegan was unable to sort out the issue until Fan Li came with his toys in the market.... The first option was to install an enterprise resource planning system such as SAP, the second was to rewrite the system using internal resources and third was to outsource the system development to a third party (Upton and Staats 2008b, 3)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Was Outsourcing the A/P Project the Right Move for Tegan Given the Other Possible Alternatives

The A/p system was based on an old copy of a packaged software system, named Dunnock, which has been tailored to the emerging needs inwardly and outwardly many times.... Out of various alternatives, one alternative with the IT department was to work on an enterprise resource planning system (ERP) to include the financial accounting module in the presently undergoing SAP but the huge investment ( £ 5 million) was a major hurdle in the way (Upton and Staats, “Tegan” 3)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

P and Q Inventory Management Systems

ixed-Order Interval System (P-System) The p system of inventory management possesses various similarities as well as dissimilarities to the Q system inventory model.... Hence, the fundamental difference between the Q system and the p system can be identified as the treatment of highly demanded commodities (in case of Q system) and other goods (in case of p system).... It is due to this reason that managers prefer implementing specific methods to manage the inventories of different commodities such as the Q system and the p system....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Recommendation for E-Business Systems and Enterprise Business System

The paper "Recommendation for E-Business Systems and Enterprise Business system" discusses that adoption of the latest technology is a guarantee of success to any business.... The Internet has become a very crucial tool in the operations of many businesses.... hellip; Generally, the Internet has allowed companies to venture into e-business, where they save a lot in terms of advertising while at the same time reaching out to customers from all ends of the globe....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Business Information System - Competitive Advantage over Competitors

This paper "Business Information system - Competitive Advantage over Competitors" focuses on the business information system (BIS) which is only as good as the people who designed it in the first place.... nbsp;… This means a good BIS software should take into account not only a firm's present needs for the system but future uses as well.... This means a good accounting system must be able to provide timely and accurate data to guide management in making its important decisions that will determine whether the firm will be profitable or not or if it will survive for another year despite all the competitive odds against it....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Systems Analysis - Adopting a Mac System in LM Photography

… The paper “Systems Analysis - Adopting a Mac system in LM Photography” is a spectacular example of a case study on information technology.... They are to use Macintosh operating system.... The paper “Systems Analysis - Adopting a Mac system in LM Photography” is a spectacular example of a case study on information technology.... They are to use a Macintosh operating system.... There is, therefore, a need that the system is upgraded to use the Macintosh operating system....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us