StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Debate on Sexual Inequality - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Debate on Sexual Inequality" argues why men hold the most powerful economic and political positions across the globe, what theorists from functionalists, conflict theorists, symbolic interactionists, and feminist groups would offer to make this situation more gender-equitable…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
Debate on Sexual Inequality
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Debate on Sexual Inequality"

Summary The first article to be reviewed for the purpose of this paper is by Janet S. Chafetz d, ‘Feminist Theory and Sociology: Underutilized Contributions for Mainstream Theory’. This article critically looks at varied feminist theories that have evolved in the last two decades within sociology. The author agrees that sociology as a discipline has made many inroads in incorporating feminist apprehensions and views into its academic discourse however, it still has much to gain from their insights. Focusing only on theories written after the return of feminist activism and realization in the 1960s, it expresses how these theories originate from, appraise and modify academic traditions to reflect centrality of gender within different socio-cultural frameworks. Thus, helping us understand the wide display of theoretical ideas available for our use and their place in conventional sociological theories. The author concludes by introducing the reader to an up-and-coming topic, “the intersection of race, class and gender”. The author opinions that though very weak theoretical efforts have been taken to produce the topic, it could transform sociological comprehension of social stratification by the interesting argument it puts forward, that, “the three forms of oppression are not separate and additive, but interactive and multiplicative in their effects”. The next summary is of the film, Two Spirits, directed by Lydia Nibley and produced and written by Russell Martin and Lydia Nibley. It traces the real life story of Fred Martinez, a Navajo teen, whose life came to an abrupt halt at 16 years, when he was brutally murdered by another young man named Murphy. The film interestingly follows a historical timeline as it explores Fred’s carefree and brave life as a nádleehí (a male-bodied individual with a female personality) and at the same time investigates traditions that were once extensively prevalent among the indigenous people of North America. The film recounts how Native Americans had once held feminine males, intersex people, masculine females and asexual people with very high regard, defining them in the English-man’s language as “two-spirit” people. Holding to their age-old beliefs they saw in these people an embodiment of two spirits, the male and the female, hence they were considered privileged and spiritually gifted. With the looming threat of an entire tradition being wiped out from among the natives, the film slowly returns to the brutal crime that took place on 16th June, 2001 in Cortez. It explores the murder site where Murphy, viciously bludgeoned Fred to death with a rock, just for being different and later bragged about it to his friends saying he, “bug-smashed a fag”. Following narratives by Paula Mitchell, Fred’s mother, Richard La Fortune, activist of the Yupik tribe, and Cathy Renna, a leader in the LGBT community, the viewer gets a very clear picture of the vile nature of the hate crime that was meted out to young Fred. This film is created so that people can understand, accept and be compassionate about issues of gender diversity and at the same time recognize and celebrate it, in view with the wiser, traditional American cultures. The director’s attempt through this film seems to be – ‘to transform through sharing’. The last article for review is the introduction chapter of the book titled, ‘The Lenses of Gender: Transforming the Debate on Sexual Inequality’ written by Sandra Lipsitz Bem. This chapter reviews the historical transformation of America’s social consciousness with regard to philosophy and treatment of women. It traces historical beliefs regarding women in religious light and how it later took biological leanings. It depicts how these beliefs were further challenged by the women’s rights movement in the mid-nineteenth century and later by feminist advocacy in the early 1960s. However, the author believes that even within these changing times there exist “lenses of gender” which seek to infuse male power into social institutions and social reality, methodically and invisibly. Identifying the three lenses of gender as being – androcentrism, gender polarization and biological essentialism, the author considers them to be ways by which culture is reproducing male power. If a path can be devised to stop these discourses and enculturation, the author trusts that the feminist agenda in America can finally be achieved. In conclusion, the author critically analyzing the chapter admits that the term ‘male power’ cannot be generalized as it pertains specifically to power held by, “rich, white, heterosexual men”, and leaves out of its domain, “poor people, people of color and sexual minorities”. Finally, the chapter has been written within the context of USA, drawing from its history and culture and hence the universality of this paper is limited. Why do men hold the most powerful economic and political positions across the globe? Functionalist theorists believe that society is made up of interdependent parts, each of which plays their part in maintaining the smooth functioning of society. Their inherent belief in stability and social control is further enhanced by the common values and belief systems that the people share. This conviction in the idea of social equilibrium is asserted by values regarding family, marriage and gender roles. If, functionalists were to explain gender imbalances in powerful economic and political positions across the globe, they would state that the male-figure in the family has the role of maintaining its material uprightness, which is done by providing the family members with food and shelter and the female-figure is expected to offer emotional support and pursue nurturing traits, it is only when these two parts follow these balanced and separate roles that disruption in society can be curtailed. More men in the world hold powerful economic and political positions according to functional theorists because they have an influential role to play in the world, unless this is followed, the entire family system, currently prevalent in society will collapse and lead to chaos. They profess the ideology of leaving pecuniary activities to the male head and the household activities to the female subordinate. The conflict theorists are often viewed as being complete opposite to functional theorists because of their view that consensus is only achieved in society through exercise of power and control. They view patriarchal systems as institutionalized mechanisms which promote power imbalances and inequality. Through patriarchy centered concentration of wealth and endogamous marriages, conflict theorists state that dominance of men and subservience of women is ensured. To explain gender imbalances in powerful economic and political positions across the globe, these theorists would state that if women gained powerful economic and political positions, it would ensure that their economic powers would also amplify thereby increasing their control inside the home and ensuring equality. However, since this is undesirable, women are engaged in unpaid domestic chores with no power to pay for substitutes or insist on sharing of burden. Symbolic interactionists assert that the concept of gender does not exist independently but emerges from a socially constructed course. It is derived from the interaction with others and is best understood as the enactment of a scene operating from a script. Hence, if symbolic interactionists were to explain gender imbalances in powerful economic and political positions across the globe, they would state that the gender roles are prearranged to follow a set script. The labels each gender has assigned to the other, colored by a gendered subculture, establish a perception of difference. Once this is done, it becomes easier for men to justify inequality in economic and political positions as being privileged, since they have more power. The last point of view to be discussed in this paper is that of the feminists, who affirm that women should be given the opportunity to exert control over their own destinies. They believe that social inequalities are maintained by principles recognized by both the oppressor and the oppressed and they can be challenged only when the oppressed group focuses on their ability to gather resources from a variety of sources. To explain gender imbalances in powerful economic and political positions across the globe, feminist theorists state that one needs to analyze not just the gendered dimensions but also the class and race dimensions. Majority of women across the globe do not suffer from just a single oppression but from multiple oppressions, like for example, being a African-American single mother or a Dalit girl which prevent them from achieving high economic and political positions. When women try to apply for high-paying economic positions, it is not just patriarchal leanings that come into play but racial and class leanings as well. What social policies would theorists from functionalist, conflict theorist, symbolic interactionist and feminist groups offer as mechanisms to make this situation more gender equitable? Functional theorists would promote social policies on education, social security and healthcare supported by the welfare state as it would ease the burden on the family roles. In such a household then, women will be able to reprise their role merely as nurturers and extend it to career achiever, also with growing freedom for the male from his needs providing role, some of the domestic chores could be divided to ensure a more gender equitable situation. Feminists would encourage social policies discouraging inequalities based on gender, race and class. Similarly policies, supporting financial benefits for single mothers, desisting domestic violence and promoting maternity benefits would be highly regarded in the bid to promote gender equality. References Bem, Sandra Lipsitz. "Introduction." Bem, Sandra Lipsitz. The Lenses of Gender: Transforming the Debate on Sexual Inequality. Binghamton, NY: Yale University Press, 1994. 256. Chafetz, Janet Saltzman. "Feminist Theory and Sociology: Underutilized Contributions for Mainstream Theory." Annual Review of Sociology 23 (1997): 97-120. Two Spirits. By Russell Martin and Lydia Nibley. Dir. Lydia Nibley. Perf. Craig Benally. Prods. Russell Martin and Lydia Nibley. 2009. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Debate on Sexual Inequality Literature review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 1, n.d.)
Debate on Sexual Inequality Literature review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 1. https://studentshare.org/gender-sexual-studies/1793261-introduction-to-the-sociology-of-of-gender
(Debate on Sexual Inequality Literature Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1)
Debate on Sexual Inequality Literature Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/gender-sexual-studies/1793261-introduction-to-the-sociology-of-of-gender.
“Debate on Sexual Inequality Literature Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1”. https://studentshare.org/gender-sexual-studies/1793261-introduction-to-the-sociology-of-of-gender.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Debate on Sexual Inequality

Benefits of Equal Distribution of Wealth and Income in the United States

Name: College: Course: Tutor: Date: Benefits of Equal Distribution of Wealth and Income in the United States Income and wealth inequality in the United States and the rest of the world has been increasing steadily in the last four decades.... hellip; Although people are now more aware than ever before of the income and wealth disparity that exists in the United States, the level of inequality is considerably higher than they think it is.... This is the reason why the government has taken little action to reduce this inequality, despite the numerous debates for and against government intervention to reduce it....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Locating Equality: A Personal Perspective

It is quite evident from the debate spurred on by the words and the battle that ensued afterwards in defense of the inalienable human rights that Jefferson and his co-drafters of the Declaration of Independence did not actually intend to actualize the ideal, inclusive meaning of equality for all men as it is today....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Philosophy (practical ethics)

The greatest harm done, feels Mackinnon, is the inequality it creates.... The traditional view is that pornography is any sexually explicit material that generates sexual arousal in the consumers.... As it encourages sexual promiscuity and as it is morally and religiously bad, it should not be permitted in society....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Work and Professional Development

Chairman of the review Trevor Phillips, who is head of the new Commission for Equality and Human Rights, said inequality was still a major problem in the UK and was now preventing the majority of people from achieving their potential.... There has been much debate about initiatives that seek to promote equality of opportunity irrespective of gender, race and other social categories.... The debate has centred around the effectiveness of the… Equality initiatives have been present in academic institutions for some time now....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Rights of Women and the Rights of Humans

The rights of women are violated through domestic violence such as battering meted at them, sexual discrimination, workplace discrimination on the basis of their genders, decision making in the political processes and many other areas.... One topic inside the larger debate of human rights that has become very controversial in the recent past is the rights of women....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Grassroots Activism Project

Additionally, it is the line of action that ensure functionality of the organization that does not reinforce or conceal patterns of gender inequality in its staffing, functions and governance.... In pursuing this line of action, gender inequality will come to be history in the society because it takes a multi-pronged dimension in redressing the social problem of gender inequality In the spirit of programmatic gender mainstreaming a number of action are taken to ensure that the issue of gender inequality is solved....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Political Culture of the United States

As for equality, some suggest that all citizens should be recognized as equal and goods and services should be equally distributed, while others favor natural inequality as a result of one's personal endeavor.... A part of the nation argues that marriages as a personal matter and the government cannot dictate who to marry; furthermore, sexual minorities should be seen as equal to ordinary citizens....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Are Equality and Freedom Mutually Incompatible

"Are Equality and Freedom Mutually Incompatible" paper centers on the premise of equality and freedom being incompatible from a number of perspectives on this day.... Equality and freedom cannot be deemed compatible because there are elements that wouldn't let the 2 integrate and form a cohesive basis....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us