StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Textbook Making Modern Science by Peter Bowler and Iwan Morus - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Textbook Making Modern Science by Peter Bowler and Iwan Morus" states that science and technology are now and have always been interconnected. Overall the chapter raises only one question, namely whether science or technology is more important…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Textbook Making Modern Science by Peter Bowler and Iwan Morus
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Textbook Making Modern Science by Peter Bowler and Iwan Morus"

?History of Science: Review a chapter of Peter Bowler and Iwan Morus’s textbook Making Modern Science. Chapter 17 of Bowler and Morus’s textbook on the history of science1 is entitled “Science and Technology” and it deals with the increasingly close connection between these two phenomena in the modern world. The main point of the chapter is to point out that this was not always the case and show how and why this close proximity of the two areas has happened in relatively recent times. Citing the scholar Latour,2 the authors maintain (p. 393) that modern terms such “technoscience” suggest that the technology and science are identical. In fact, however, scientists and historians have argued for many centuries about the differences between the two, suggesting that pure science is hierarchically different from its applications in the world of work. The chapter explains how some thinkers place science above technology, and others place science below technology, in importance. The authors finally come to the conclusion that the best way to think about these two things is to observe examples and conclude that “little practical distinction is made between the two.” (p. 401) The authors start with recent times and argue that the most common view in the twentieth century was that science was more pure, and more important because it dealt with ideas and truths. Technology was considered a lesser area of study because it was concerned with merely things. It could be said that this is an idealist position, because it is theoretical, and imaginary, rather than concrete and applied. An interesting aspect of the authors’ approach is that it also brings in cultural and political factors. Scientists often see things through a narrow lens, in terms of numbers and theories, as if these things are absolute, but this chapter shows that ideas like Marxism influenced science. This ideology strongly favors a materialistic view of things, and stresses the usefulness of ideas in the real world. For scientists in Soviet Russia, then, technology was seen as more important. Scientists in the Capitalist western countries, on the other hand, continued with old ideas from the Enlightenment, which favored the theoretical over the practical. Another useful comparison is drawn (pp. 396-397) between French and English government approaches to the funding of science in the nineteenth century. In France the government wanted to promote science for its wealth-bringing potential, and funded research very generously, while in Britain there was a more relaxed attitude which left research to be more of a gentleman’s hobby which was funded by private money. Looking at the world of science today it is interesting to see that these same old debates are still very relevant, because scientists always have to seek various sources of funding for their work. The American contribution to this debate was to emphasize the importance of inventors like Morse and Edison, who used their craft skills and intelligence to improve existing designs and create completely new ones. These men referred to traditional scientists, also, when they needed to solve some problems, which goes to show that theory and practice need to work together if progress is to be made. The chapter contains a number of headings, some of which are indicators of a particular example such as “steam culture” while others are more fancy such as “the chicken and the egg” and “invisible technicians.” These fancy headings do not help the reader to work out what the next topic is going to be. Unlike most historical textbooks, this one does not present the facts in chronological order, since it jumps back and forward through the ages, following the arguments for and against the supremacy of science or technology. This can be confusing, since at first it is not clear which way the authors wish the reader to follow. This is a weakness in the chapter, because a lot of the time the reader feels lost, and wondering what the point is that the authors want to make. After several pages, however, it becomes clear that the message emerging out of the examples is that both science and technology are equally important. This is point is repeated again and again, which becomes rather boring. It could be said that the argument develops by stating for and against, several times, and then ending in the middle. The summing up begins on page 411 but it uses very elaborate language: “It should be clear from these examples that there has been more at stake historically in deciding the relationship between science and technology than just philosophy or epistemological nicety.” This chapter would have been improved by a smaller number of examples and a clearer indication of where the pro argument is, and where the con argument is. The way it stands, there is a bit of a muddle in the center part of the chapter. One way of checking the current American view of this argument is to look at Government structure, and it is interesting to note that there is no department of science, or department of technology, but that there is an “Office of Science and Technology Policy” 3 This suggests that the authors’ view is valid. The best features of this chapter are a) the illustrations and b) the conclusion. The illustrations are good because they are taken from real books dating from the time of the arguments which are being discussed. So for example there are pictures of people (for example Samuel Morse on page 405) and machines, which gives a realistic impression of what is being talked about and who is speaking. In particular the costumes remind us that some of these arguments took place hundreds of years ago and the images are drawings, or perhaps engravings, which reminds us that everything was done without modern writing and calculation aids. The conclusion is good because it moves on from the boring and repetitive arguments that have gone before, and states some of the implications of these arguments as they continue into the present day. It shows that science and technology are now and have always been interconnected. Overall the chapter raises only one question, namely whether science or technology is more important, and it fails to answer the question, but does explain some of the political and ideological issues which make question reappear again and again. References Bowler, Peter and Morus, Iwan. Making Modern Science: a historical survey. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005. Chapter 17 “Science and Technology”, pp. 391 – 414. Latour, Bruno. Science in Action: How to Follow Scientists and Engineers through Society. Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1987. “Structure of the United States Government”. Available at: http://www.theusgov.com/ Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“History of Science - review a chapter of Peter Bowler and Iwan Morus's Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1414953-history-of-science-review-a-chapter-of-peter
(History of Science - Review a Chapter of Peter Bowler and Iwan Morus'S Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1414953-history-of-science-review-a-chapter-of-peter.
“History of Science - Review a Chapter of Peter Bowler and Iwan Morus'S Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1414953-history-of-science-review-a-chapter-of-peter.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Textbook Making Modern Science by Peter Bowler and Iwan Morus

Textbook Prices

“A Cover to Cover Solution: How Open Textbooks are the Path to textbook Affordability" is given an in-depth overview in this paper.... Bernard Tara Siegel “For Class, Book Deals”, Bruno Laura “College Books for Less”, Smith Craig “Law that Takes Effect in July Aimed at Controlling textbook Costs”, these are some of the papers that were characterised in current annotated bibliography.... “A Cover to Cover Solution: How Open Textbooks are the Path to textbook Affordability....
4 Pages (1000 words) Annotated Bibliography

Curbing the Costs of College Textbooks

Publishers say the price increase is in keeping with the rising costs of printing, along with the expenses related to paying textbook writers, and fact-checkers.... The author states that the best and most fair solution for everyone when it comes to textbook pricing is to move away from physical printed and bound books to electronic and downloadable texts.... The best and most fair solution for everyone when it comes to textbook pricing is to move away from physical printed and bound books to electronic and downloadable texts....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Textbook Analysis 5

he textbook is a.... After introductory chapters on the nexus of history, archaeology and geography and conditions of humans during the Paleolithic and Neolithic Eras, the balance of the textbook addresses the history and The books is mostly organized according to chronology of the civilizations and roughly sectioned according to geographic location.... These discussions and readings are a strength of this textbook.... Each one of these section assessments asks questions typical of a social studies textbook....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

High Cost of Textbooks - Problem-Solution

For example, books on science and technology fields are far more likely to require constant updating for new information, facts and findings than a book about English literature in the 19th century.... (Bernard 5) Downloadable Books Another technology-based solution that even publishers like is making the textbooks available online for students to download.... This is something they have been doing for years and clearly it is making money for them, or they wouldn't be doing it....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

College textbook price

In his descriptive article, How Students are paying less for College textbook Spors Kelly presented his thoughts on Wall Street Journal in 2005 on how students are paying less for college textbooks.... On the contrary, the article College textbook Prices at Twice the inflation confirms that college textbooks are increasing at a high rate and publishers have largely contributed to the high prices of textbooks.... The aim of this paper is to discuss two articles that disagree with each others and in doing will summarize and compile information of each article with its view on textbook prices....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Role Women played in the Scientific Revolution of the 18th Century and Science Today

From this work "Role Women played in the Scientific Revolution of the 18th Century and science Today" it is clear that women are discriminated against and underrepresented in the field of science.... But feminists discourses have contested this position pointing to the way science has evolved to become highly 'masculine' focusing more on exploitation and destruction rather than constructive coexistence and peace.... Especially how science has developed a way of looking at nature and weaker sections of human society has come under the critical scanner....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Marketing in the Textbook Industry

making the choice of what books to purchase have been complex enough to many people.... The introduction of electronic textbook as a competing model has made it more difficult.... The electronic textbook model has its attention on the changing technology advancement and increasing computer literacy.... Customers allied to the traditional textbooks format value the reading ease, the resale value, the personal library idea The paper 'Marketing and Key Factors of Success in the textbook Industry" is an informative variant of the assignment on marketing....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Analysis of an English Language Textbook

No wonder the education system in Saudi Arabia aims at offering its students adeptness in English so as to make them acquire appropriate knowledge in various fields: new inventions, arts, and science fields.... This case study "Analysis of an English Language textbook" presents an education system in Saudi Arabia territory that is governed by a general principle that stipulates that every individual citizen; young or adult, is entitled to pursue learning.... The textbook was chosen because it was recently published and hence if accepted to be taught at grade four level, it will lead to the future success of English language teaching in the country....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us